Oprah’s lengthy historical past with junk science

After Oprah delivered her epic Golden Globes speech on Sunday, #Oprah2020 was all of the sudden a factor.

Everybody from Ivanka Trump to Ron Howard praised her inspiring oratory, and celebrities like Woman Gaga stated they’d vote for her if she have been to run for president. Even hard-nosed political observers, together with Nate Cohn and Nate Silver, identified she could be an actual contender.

Oprah has reportedly denied any curiosity within the White Home, however that hasn’t stopped individuals from questioning what an Oprah presidency might appear to be — and what scrutiny she’d face if she actually harbors political ambitions.

Since persons are clamoring for her to run as an answer to our nation’s issues, we needed to focus on one space through which the broadcaster, billionaire, and philanthropist has a reasonably doubtful file: science.

Throughout her 25-year reign as host of The Oprah Winfrey Present, from 1986 to 2011, Oprah repeatedly confirmed a weak point for crackpots and quack medical theories. One might even argue that she’s one of the crucial highly effective enablers of cranks on the planet. Right here’s a fast rundown of a few of her worst assaults on motive and scientific pondering.


In 2004, Dr. Ozmade his first look on The Oprah Winfrey Present, the place he was known as “America’s Physician” (a moniker he trademarked). As a daily medical knowledgeable on Oprah, he used the platform to again a spread of questionable well being practices, together with lending credibility to the Brazilian spirit medium and well-known huckster ”John of God.”

The Oprah seal of approval helped Ozget his personal present by 2009. Her instincts about his potential have been good, in a way: Ozis immensely widespread, and his media empire now extends to books, magazines, radio, web sites, and, after all, TV. However on The Dr. OzShow, the cardiothoracic surgeon has usually promoted unhealthy science and bogus well being recommendation.

In 2014, Ozwas known as earlier than a Senate subcommittee on client safety. He was requested by the senator in cost, Claire McCaskill, to elucidate his use of “flowery” language to champion weight reduction fixes that don’t really work. She then admonished him for endorsing a rainbow of dietary supplements as potential “stomach blasters” and “mega metabolism boosters.” As McCaskill put it, “The scientific neighborhood is sort of monolithic in opposition to you when it comes to the efficacy of the three merchandise you known as ‘miracles.’”

In 2015, the Federal Commerce Fee discovered that Ozs producers did the scantest analysis on the present’s visitors, which allowed modern-day snake oil salesmen to look on air hawking bogus merchandise. That very same 12 months, a gaggle of professors, scientists, and docs argued that the present was so deceptive that Ozs professor place was incompatible together with his on-air work.

Ozhas additionally shared the stage with vaccine deniers, and activists like “Meals Babe” Vani Hari (identified to scientists as “the Jenny McCarthy of meals”). On the peak of the Ebola panic final 12 months, Ozinstructed the virus might go airborne — although there was common settlement amongst virologists that the pathogens have by no means behaved that approach.

All this didn’t flip Oprah off of Oz. He stays a daily contributor to her extensively learn O journal and her web site, and she or he nonetheless seems on his present.


Regardless of his medical shenanigans, Dr. Ozhas an precise medical diploma to his identify. Dr. Phil, however, doesn’t (he holds a doctorate in psychology and isn’t a licensed psychologist). However that minor element didn’t cease Oprah from utilizing the “Dr.” moniker on the entrance of his identify.

McGraw additionally obtained his begin on Oprah’s present, after assembly the TV star whereas working together with her as a marketing consultant when she was being (unsuccessfully) sued for making destructive statements concerning the beef business in 1995. By the late 1990s, Dr. Phil began showing on her present as a life coach, and in 2002 he launched his personal eponymous present.

Like Dr. Oz, McGraw has been censured for utilizing his superstar and his present for ethically doubtful practices. In 2016, he was criticized for peddling diabetes prescription drugs by way of paid sponsorships that have been masquerading as pleasant recommendation a couple of illness from a trusted supply.

And final December, a Stat investigation uncovered some unethical behind-the-scenes practices on the present, together with giving vodka to a visitor who was battling alcoholism and asking different visitors with extreme drug addictions to purchase medication on the road — all for the needs of leisure.

“It’s a callous and inexcusable exploitation,” Dr. Jeff Sugar, an assistant professor of medical psychiatry on the College of Southern California, informed Stat. “These persons are barely hanging on. It’s like if one in all them was drowning and approaching a lifeboat, and as a substitute of throwing them an inflatable doughnut, you throw them an anchor.”

Like Dr. Oz, McGraw continues to be a daily contributor to O journal, and the Dr. Phil present nonetheless airs on the Oprah Winfrey Community.


Actress, Playboy mannequin, and pseudoscience peddler Jenny McCarthy has been an ardent anti-vaccine advocate. She helped propel the discredited British physician Andrew Wakefield, who has argued that vaccines trigger autism based mostly on his personal fraudulent analysis, to fame. (McCarthy even co-authored an anti-vax e book in 2011 with Wakefield, titled Callous Disregard.) Within the media, she’s claimed that vaccines gave her son Evan autism, and that she was in a position to “remedy” him by way of a particular weight loss plan and dietary supplements.

In fact, the notion that vaccines trigger autism has by no means been supported by science. However Oprah gave McCarthy an unlimited viewers through her TV present in 2007. Science journalist Seth Mnookin, who lined this assembly of the minds in his e book The Panic Virus, reported that Winfrey “praised McCarthy’s unwillingness to bow to authority, her religion in herself, and her use of the Web as a instrument for bypassing society’s conventional gatekeepers.” Right here’s an excerpt from the interview transcript:

MCCARTHY: Very first thing I did — Google. I put in autism. And I began my analysis.

WINFREY: Thank God for Google.

MCCARTHY: I’m telling you.

WINFREY: Thank God for Google.

MCCARTHY: The College of Google is the place I obtained my diploma from. … And I put in autism and one thing got here up that modified my life, that led me on this highway to restoration, which stated autism — it was within the nook of the display — is reversible and treatable. And I stated, What?! That needs to be an advert for a hocus-pocus factor, as a result of if autism is reversible and treatable, nicely, then it could be on Oprah.

Days after that Oprah look, McCarthy was invited on Larry King Dwell and Good Morning America to unfold her anti-vaccine message even additional. Between the three reveals, she reached between 15 million and 20 million viewers together with her anti-vaccine message, Mnookin estimated.

To today, the episode that includes McCarthy, “Moms Battle Autism,” is featured on Oprah’s web site, with none correction or acknowledgment of the issues with McCarthy’s claims.

For extra about Oprah’s relationship with junk science, learn David Gorski’s nice rundown on his weblog Respectful Insolence. You too can learn my explainer about Andrew Wakefield and my function about Dr. Ozs rise to fame.

Show More

Related Articles